Skip to main content

click zoom to display a high-res image
Property Record

143 S 3RD AVE

Historic Name:
Augustus W. Lawrence, Sr. Property
Other Name:
Reference Number:
49769

Property Location

Location (Address)
143 S 3RD AVE
County
Door
City/Village
Sturgeon Bay
Township
Unincorporated community
Town
Range
Direction
Section
Quarter Section
Quarter Quarter Section

Property Features

Year Built
1856
Additions
C. 1880,C. 1930
Survey Date
2006
Historic Use
Architectural Style
Structural System
Wall Material
Clapboard
Architect
Other Buildings On Site
Demolished
No
Demolished Date
Additional Comments
This 1 1/2 story clapboard sided house has a broad, gabled facade facing the street that is pierced by plainly detailed, paired windows on the lower level and a single one on the upper. This configuration is unique within the city. The most noteworthy detail is the small entry porch that is supported by turned wood posts. The porch gable is decorated with sunburst motif and a scroll sawn spandrel apron beneath. This simple vernacular building is of architectural interest because of its intact detailing and novel massing.

This house has a rebuilt old-style porch with simple doric columns (2000).

June 2006-This one and one half story, front gabled, clapboard sheathed house features an open, shed roof porch with Doric column supports and a plain balustrade. The porch shelters a single door that is flanked to either side by a pair of two over two, double hung sashes, while a single sash window rests within the gabled peak. Windows throughout the remainder of the house are double hung, wooden sash examples-all of which are replacements. Historic maps suggest that this house was originally oriented to the south and featured a full-width porch along that facade. At some point the south porch was removed and a new, smaller porch was fitted along the home's S. Third Avenue elevation. The current owners located an old porch railing in the basement and made the existing, east facing one to match.

Research suggests that this house was built by Augustus W. Lawrence, Sr., in 1856. Lawrence purchased the subject lot from Robert Graham, who was responsible for platting the section in which this residence stands and for whom Lawrence, Sr., first worked upon arriving in Sturgeon Bay. Lawrence was born in Maine and moved to Sturgeon Bay in 1852. In 1856, he was associated with Charnley Bros. & Co.; that same year they erected a sawmill. After serving as superintendent of that business until 1878, Lawrence organized the Sturgeon Bay Lumber Company. In addition, in 1865, he began a mercantile business which was named the A.W. Lawrence & Co. Fifteen years later, Lawrence erected a new, two story store building for the business in Sturgeon Bay. The firm also had a branch store in Bay View which, at that time, was the community located immediately south of the canal and bridge. Deeds indicate that the house was under the ownership of Lawrence Sr. for just five years. It is unclear, however, if the subject house was Lawrence, Sr.'s, personal property or if it was part of the lumber company's holdings. According to tax rolls, William K. Dresser, an employee of the Charnley Bros. mill, is identified as the owner from 1861 until his death in 1878; however, deeds offer additional sales and names over the next few years. The lot then changed hands numerous times over the next decade. This lot, as well as the neighboring lot to the north (Lot 4, known as Anderson's Livery), were owned by the same person from at least 1887 to 1955.

Information provided by the home's current owner Trudy Herbst, the house appears to have originally consisted of just two rooms-both exhibit wide, pine board flooring and thick, vertical cedar plank walls; foundations also appear to be constructed of the same stone. Prior to 1885, two additional rooms were added to the north (both feature thin-strip mahogany flooring) and, eventually two rooms and a bathroom were added onto the rear of the house. It appears that the house achieved its current appearance between 1911 and 1928. During the ten years that Herbst and her husband have owned the home, they have done a significant amount of restoration work, including the window replacement.
Bibliographic References
A. Sanborn Perris Maps of Sturgeon Bay, 1885. Trudy Herbst, Current owner. Stanley Green research papers, in possession of the Door County Historical Society Tax Rolls, Village of Sturgeon Bay Tax Rolls, City of Sturgeon Bay

National And State Register Of Historic Places Listings

National/State Register Listing Name
Not Listed
National Register Listing Date
State Register Listing Date
Contributing
Unique ID
HI49769

Architecture & History Inventory

The Wisconsin Architecture and History Inventory (AHI) is a digital source of information on historic buildings, structures, and objects that have been surveyed by the State Historic Preservation Office in Wisconsin. Each property has a digital record providing basic information about the property and images.

Learn More about AHI

Contact Us

Questions?

Wondering about if your property is eligible or notice some information on this property needs to be updated, reach out today!

Email Us

Attribution

For a credit line: Wisconsin Historical Society, Creator, Title, Unique Identifier. 

The Unique Identifier can be found at the top or bottom of the page for each item. The name of a downloaded file is NOT the unique identifier.

For bibliographic citations please consult the UW-Madison Libraries Citation Research Guide to ensure compliance with appropriate style guidelines.

 

Access Property Records

Some properties have more materials (correspondence, clippings, historical information, etc.) not in the digital record. If a 'Site File' exists, it's noted in the 'Additional Comments' field. Contact us for an appointment to view these materials.

Schedule Appointment

Property Record
154 S 3RD AVE

154 S 3RD AVE

49770

Located in Sturgeon Bay, Door County

View Property
Property Record
1234 S 9TH ST

1234 S 9TH ST

135819

Located in Manitowoc, Manitowoc County

View Property
Property Record
613 LOUISIANA ST (aka 611 LOUISIANA ST)

613 LOUISIANA ST (aka 611 LOUISIANA ST)

50093

Located in Sturgeon Bay, Door County

View Property
Property Record
1201 S 8TH ST

1201 S 8TH ST

57364

Located in Manitowoc, Manitowoc County

View Property
Property Record
465 N ELM ST

465 N ELM ST

46086

Located in Platteville, Grant County

View Property
Property Record
9314 N 60TH ST

9314 N 60TH ST

8647

Located in Brown Deer, Milwaukee County

View Property
Go to top
Wisconsin Historical Society
Search Dropdown