Skip to main content

click zoom to display a high-res image
Property Record

343 N BROADWAY (A.K.A. 225 E ST PAUL AVE)

Historic Name:
Merchant Mills Block
Other Name:
Third Ward Cafe
Reference Number:
16136

Property Location

Location (Address)
343 N BROADWAY (A.K.A. 225 E ST PAUL AVE)
County
Milwaukee
City/Village
Milwaukee
Township
Unincorporated community
Town
Range
Direction
Section
Quarter Section
Quarter Quarter Section

Property Features

Year Built
1865
Additions
1875
Survey Date
2000,2010
Historic Use
Architectural Style
Structural System
Wall Material
Brick
Architect
Edward Townsend Mix
Other Buildings On Site
Demolished
No
Demolished Date
Additional Comments
SEE HAER FORM. BUILT FOR JEWETT AND SHERMAN, PURVEYORS OF COFFEE AND SPICES. Original cost of building was $35,000. M IN THE PHOTO CODES IS SHORT FOR MVIS NEGATIVES.

This four-story sandblasted cream brick building is designed in the Victorian Gothic style with foliate designs on the keystones, pointed arches, an arcuated cornice and projecting string courses. The original double-hung windows have been replaced in part by fixed panes. The (Jewett & Sherman Co.) Merchant Mills Block is significant as one of the oldest intact industrial buildings in the city. Its architectual detail is exceptionally fine for an industrial structure.

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND AND SIGNIFICANCE:

This mill construction building is one of a handful of survivors of the 1892 fire. It was built in 1875 and occupied for 45 years by Jewett & Sherman Co.'s Merchant Mills. The Jewett and Sherman Building anchors the north end of the block-long "Commission Row," the heart of the city's wholesale produce trade since the turn of the century. The block is notable for its long, rhythmic façade created by the repetition of projecting brick piers and other simple architectural elements. To most visitors, Commission Row looks quiet, but early every weekday morning it still throngs with fruit and flower merchants loading their trucks under the broad metal awnings.

Established in 1867 a block away, the firm expanded from preparing and jobbing coffee and spices to manufacturing baking powder, dry and prepared mustard, flavoring extracts, essence of coffee and bluing. The firm was reputed to have one of the most extensive selections of these goods, and was described as one of the busiest institutions in Milwaukee in 1892. In 1940 the building was used as a commission house, then for offices and a restaurant. It was remodeled in 1977 for produce storage, with a restaurant on the first floor and artist's studios and offices on the second to fourth floors. What was the "commodious" and "elegant" home of one of Milwaukee's most prominent firms a century ago has lost much of its ornamentation and has suffered fire damage, but still stands as the oldest manufacturing building in the Third Ward.

Resurveyed for Milwaukee Downtown Connector Arch/History Survey, SHPO#10-0983, Prepared by Heritage Research (2010).
Bibliographic References
BUILT IN MILWAUKEE, LANDSCAPE RESEARCH, P. 80. Flower, History of Milwaukee, 1881, pp. 1208-09.f Milwaukee, 1881, pp. 1208-09. Historic Third Ward Historic Walking Tour, Historic Third Ward Association, 2009. Buildings of Wisconsin manuscript.

National And State Register Of Historic Places Listings

National/State Register Listing Name
Historic Third Ward District
National Register Listing Date
Mar 08, 1984
State Register Listing Date
Jan 01, 1989
Contributing
Yes
Permalink
Permalink

Architecture & History Inventory

The Wisconsin Architecture and History Inventory (AHI) is a digital source of information on historic buildings, structures, and objects that have been surveyed by the State Historic Preservation Office in Wisconsin. Each property has a digital record providing basic information about the property and images.

Learn More about AHI

Contact Us

Questions?

Wondering about if your property is eligible or notice some information on this property needs to be updated, reach out today!

Email Us

Attribution

For a credit line: Wisconsin Historical Society, Creator, Title, Unique Identifier. 

The Unique Identifier can be found at the top or bottom of the page for each item. The name of a downloaded file is NOT the unique identifier.

For bibliographic citations please consult the UW-Madison Libraries Citation Research Guide to ensure compliance with appropriate style guidelines.

 

Access Property Records

Some properties have more materials (correspondence, clippings, historical information, etc.) not in the digital record. If a 'Site File' exists, it's noted in the 'Additional Comments' field. Contact us for an appointment to view these materials.

Schedule Appointment

Property Record
400 N BROADWAY ST

400 N BROADWAY ST

98163

Located in Milwaukee, Milwaukee County

View Property
Property Record
316 N MILWAUKEE ST

316 N MILWAUKEE ST

29154

Located in Milwaukee, Milwaukee County

View Property
Property Record
302 N BROADWAY ST / 300 E BUFFALO ST

302 N BROADWAY ST / 300 E BUFFALO ST

16561

Located in Milwaukee, Milwaukee County

View Property
Property Record
207 N MILWAUKEE ST (AKA 318 E CHICAGO ST)

207 N MILWAUKEE ST (AKA 318 E CHICAGO ST)

110936

Located in Milwaukee, Milwaukee County

View Property
Property Record
141 N WATER ST

141 N WATER ST

71331

Located in Milwaukee, Milwaukee County

View Property
Property Record
217 N BROADWAY ST

217 N BROADWAY ST

98326

Located in Milwaukee, Milwaukee County

View Property
Go to top
Wisconsin Historical Society
Search Dropdown