Skip to main content

click zoom to display a high-res image
Property Record

226 W CHURCH ST

Historic Name:
Centernary Mathodist Church
Other Name:
CENTENARY METHODIST UNITED CHURCH
Reference Number:
74646

Property Location

Location (Address) 226 W CHURCH ST
County Lafayette
City/Village Shullsburg
Township
Unincorporated community
Town
Range
Direction
Section
Quarter Section
Quarter Quarter Section

Property Features

Year Built 1867
Additions 1898, 1971
Survey Date 1982
Historic Use house of worship
Architectural Style Italianate
Structural System
Wall Material Stone - Unspecified
Architect
Other Buildings On Site
Demolished No
Demolished Date
Additional Comments A GREEK REVIVAL INFLUENCED CHURCH STRUCTURE, 40 X 70 FT. OF NATIVE LIMESTONE FROM THE RENNICK QUARRY THAT IS ACCENTED BY A 90 FOOT HIGH STEEPLE.(D) THE SLOPING ROOF HAS A PEDIMENTED STREET FACING GABLE AND AN ITALIANATE WOODEN BRACKETED CORNICE THAT RUNS AROUND THE BUILDING, FORMING THE LOWER BORDER OF THE PEDIMENTED AREA OF THE GABLE. A WOODEN BRACKETED PEDIMENT FORMS THE HOOD OVER THE RECESSED PANELED ENTRY. BRACKETS ALSO DECORATE THE ROOF OF THE STEEPLE BASE. A DECORATIVE PATTERN OF CUT SHINGLES COVER THE STEEPLE THAT IS TOPPED BY A FINIAL. STONE QUOINS AT THE CORNERS OF THE STRUCTURE AND STONE LINTELS OVER THE WINDOWS CHARACTERIZE THE STRUCTURE. ROUND ARCHED WINDOWS IN THE STEEPLE CONTRAST WITH THE SIMPLE RECTANGULAR WINDOWS OF THE MAIN STRUCTURE. STAINED GLASS WINDOWS WERE ADDED TO THE CHURCH IN 1897. A STONE PARSONAGE WAS ADDED TO THE COMPLEX IN 1960 AND A STONE ADDITION TO THE SOUTH WAS ADDED IN 1971. THE CHURCH HAS OBVIOUS ARCHITECTURAL SIGNIFICANCE AS AN EXCELLENT EXAMPLE OF MID-CENTURY VERNACULAR GREEK REVIVAL CHURCH ARCHITECTURE WITH THE USUAL ADDED ITALIANATE FEATURES, A COMBINATION COMMONLY FOUND IN ARCHITECTURE FROM THIS PERIOD. IN ADDITION, THIS CHURCH IS IMPORTANT AS A VISUAL LANDMARK IN THE TOWN OF SHULLSBURG SINCE THE EARLY DAYS OF ITS DEVELOPMENT. THIS CHURCH IS IMPORTANT TO THE RELIGIOUS DEVELOPMENT OF THE COMMUNITY. BY THE 1820S, THE METHODIST MOVEMENT WAS WORKING THE WESTERN FRONTIER. THE EARLIEST KNOWN PREACHER IN THE SHULLSBURG AREA WAS JOB DEW, WHO WAS APPOINTED TO WORK THE GALENA CIRCUIT ON THE FEVER RIVER. DEW FIRST HELD SERVICES IN GRATIOT'S GROVE IN 1828.(A) THE FIRST REGULARLY HELD METHODIST MEETINGS WERE AT THE SHULLSBURG SCHOOL HOUSE BEGINNING IN 1845.(C) THE FIRST PASTOR, REV. ISAAC SEARLES, WAS SERVING THE COUNCIL HILL CIRCUIT WHICH INCLUDED HAZEL GREEN, BENTON, NEW DIGGINGS, AND COUNCIL HILL. A SMALL FRAME CHURCH WAS BUILT ABOUT 1852 ON THE CORNER OF CHURCH AND GRATIOT STREETS IN SHULLSBURG.(C) THAT YEAR THE SHULLSBURG CIRCUIT WAS FORMED WITH AN AGGREGATE NUMBER OF 130 MEMBERS.(C) IN 1866, THE FRAME CHURCH WAS MOVED TO THE CORNER OF CHURCH AND IOWA STREETS. THE NEXT YEAR THE PRESENT STONE CHURCH WAS ERECTED AT A COST OF $12,000. THE STONES WERE FROM THE RENNICK QUARRY SOUTH OF THE VILLAGE. THE PARSONAGE WAS BUILT EAST OF THE CHURCH. IN THE SPRING OF 1971, THE OLD PARSONAGE WAS MOVED AND AN ADDITION WAS BUILT FOR SUNDAY SCHOOL CLASSROOMS.(A)
Bibliographic References A. "SEQ. HISTORY OF SHULLSBURG, 1827-1977" (SHULLSBURG, WI: HISTORICAL SOCIETY, 1977), P. 95. B. IBID., P. 96. C. BUTTERFIELD, "LAFAYETTE CO. HISTORY," 1881, P. 579. D. SHULLSBURG PLAT MAP, 1894.

National And State Register Of Historic Places Listings

National/State Register Listing Name Water Street Commercial Historic District
National Register Listing Date Jun 28, 1990
State Register Listing Date Jan 23, 1990
Contributing Yes
Permalink
Permalink

Architecture & History Inventory

The Wisconsin Architecture and History Inventory (AHI) is a digital source of information on historic buildings, structures, and objects that have been surveyed by the State Historic Preservation Office in Wisconsin. Each property has a digital record providing basic information about the property and images.

Learn More about AHI

Contact Us

Questions?

Wondering about if your property is eligible or notice some information on this property needs to be updated, reach out today!

Email Us

Attribution

For a credit line: Wisconsin Historical Society, Creator, Title, Unique Identifier. 

The Unique Identifier can be found at the top or bottom of the page for each item. The name of a downloaded file is NOT the unique identifier.

For bibliographic citations please consult the UW-Madison Libraries Citation Research Guide to ensure compliance with appropriate style guidelines.

 

Access Property Records

Some properties have more materials (correspondence, clippings, historical information, etc.) not in the digital record. If a 'Site File' exists, it's noted in the 'Additional Comments' field. Contact us for an appointment to view these materials.

Schedule Appointment

Property Record
SW CORNER OF CHURCH AND IOWA STS

SW CORNER OF CHURCH AND IOWA STS

74638

Located in Shullsburg, Lafayette County

View Property
Property Record
615 BROADWAY

615 BROADWAY

94714

Located in Baraboo, Sauk County

View Property
Property Record
NW CORNER OF SIDNEY AND CYCLOP STS

NW CORNER OF SIDNEY AND CYCLOP STS

80727

Located in Shullsburg, Lafayette County

View Property
Property Record
125 E STATE ST

125 E STATE ST

221282

Located in Burlington, Racine County

View Property
Property Record
172 W Main St

172 W Main St

66671

Located in Benton, Lafayette County

View Property
Property Record
344 N JUDGEMENT ST

344 N JUDGEMENT ST

29558

Located in Shullsburg, Lafayette County

View Property
Go to top
Wisconsin Historical Society
Search Dropdown